Conditions at Guantanamo Worsening, According to Amnesty Int’l

by Michael Kelly

BBC is reporting that the international NGO Amnesty International has decried worsening conditions at the U.S. military prison facility in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, where trials of detainees captured in the War on Terror have recently gotten underway:

Guantanamo conditions ‘worsening’
BBC News, April 4, 2007

Some of Guantanamo’s inmates have been held for five years. Conditions for detainees at the US military jail at Guantanamo Bay are deteriorating, with the majority held in solitary confinement, a report says. Amnesty International said the often harsh and inhumane conditions at the camp were “pushing people to the edge”. It called for the facility to be closed and for plans for “unfair” military commission trials to be abandoned. Many of the 385 inmates have been held for five years or more, unable to mount a legal challenge to their detention. “While the United States has an obligation to protect its citizens… that does not relieve the United States from its responsibilities to comply with human rights,” the report said. Some [inmates] are dangerously close to full-blown mental and physical breakdown.

“Statements by the Bush administration that these men are ‘enemy combatants,’ ‘terrorists’ or ‘very bad people’ do not justify the complete lack of due process rights,” the group said. Amnesty reiterated its call for detainees at the prison camp in Cuba - many of whom are suspected Taleban and al-Qaeda fighters - to be released or charged and sent to trial. The report, published on Thursday, said about 300 detainees are now being held at a new facility - known as Camp 5, Camp 6 and Camp Echo - comparable to “super-max” high security units in the US.

The US says it plans to prosecute 80 of the 385 remaining inmates. The group said the facility had “created even harsher and apparently more permanent conditions of extreme isolation and sensory deprivation”. It said the detainees were reportedly confined to windowless cells for 22 hours a day, only allowed to exercise at night and could go for days without seeing daylight. The organisation’s UK director, Kate Allen, described the process at Guantanamo as “a travesty of justice”. “With many prisoners already in despair at being held in indefinite detention… some are dangerously close to full-blown mental and physical breakdown. “The US authorities should immediately stop pushing people to the edge with extreme isolation techniques and allow proper access for independent medical experts and human rights groups.”

The provision that stripped detainees of their right to mount a legal challenge to their confinement was upheld by a US federal appeals court in Washington in February. Pushing the anti-terror legislation through Congress last year, Mr Bush said he needed the new law to bring terror suspects to justice. It allows for the indefinite detention of people as “enemy combatants”. The US has said it plans to use the military tribunal system to prosecute about 80 of 385 prisoners remaining at the camp.

Friday, April 6th, 2007 9:02 am | Posted in: AIDP Blog, Counterterrorism, International Criminal Law, International Human Rights Law, International Humanitarian Law
Print This Post Print This Post | Share This

3 Comments for the post: Conditions at Guantanamo Worsening, According to Amnesty Int’l

Trackback URLPermalink URL

Comment #1

john said,

Guilty or not inmates in Guatanamo should be treated humanely.
Using sensory deprivation to damage or kill thier minds is not in accordance with the good and proper mutually respectful nature of democratic people of the United states of America.
All americans wish to see the goverment that represents them conducts itself in a honourable and decent manner .
Americans pride themselves on thier democratic civilised society and wish that to be upheld.

April 7, 2007 at 3:37 pm

Comment #2

Christopher Blakesley said,

Indeed, John, it is pathetic that so many let themselves be so frightened that they are willing to participate or acquiesce in the evisceration of the morality and legality that they have either believed they stood behind (or pretended that they did). What we are willing to do or to allow to be done in our name says a lot about whom we really are.

and so it goes,

Chris

April 11, 2007 at 2:36 am

Comment #3

joe said,

According to Sarah Havens, a 29-year-old associate (and Arabic speaker) at the New York office of Allen & Overy, which represents 10 Yemeni detainees who have been at Guantánamo since 2002. Ms. Havens first visited the prison facility in early 2005 and says she has since been back about 10 times. Here is an excerpt from an interview she gave to the Wall Street Journal Law Blog (http://blogs.wsj.com/law/2007/04/27/a-conversation-with-gitmo-lawyer-on-proposed-doj-rules/) in which she states that overall treatment of detainees has improved with the presence of haebus attorneys.

April 27, 2007 at 12:39 pm

Leave Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment. Log In.

You must register to comment with a valid email address to which a password will be mailed. Additionally, your first comment will be moderated before it will appear. Not registered yet? Click here. Thank you!

The AIDP is the oldest association of criminal law specialists in the world and one of the oldest scientific associations. This blog serves as a discussion site for all things law, with a focus upon criminal law, comparative criminal justice, international criminal law, international humanitarian law, war crimes, international criminal tribunals, human rights and counterterrorism law & policy.

The Bloggers

Michael Scharf President AIDP American National SectionBiography/Contact LawFac Page SSRN

Mark Drumbl Vice President AIDP American National Section Biography/Contact LawFac Page SSRN

Christopher Blakesley Vice President AIDP American National Section Biography/Contact LawFac Page

Michael Kelly Director of Studies AIDP American National Section Biography/Contact LawFac Page SSRN

Gregory McNeal Director of Studies AIDP American National Section Biography/Contact LawFac Page SSRN

Dorean Koenig Secretary AIDP American National Section Biography/Contact LawFac Page

David Crane Biography/Contact LawFac Page

Amos Guiora Biography/Contact LawFac Page SSRN

Linda Malone Biography/Contact LawFac Page

Michael Newton Biography/Contact LawFac Page SSRN

Jordan Paust Biography/Contact LawFac Page SSRN

David Scheffer Biography/Contact LawFac Page

Laura Dickinson Biography/Contact LawFac Page

Leila Sadat Biography/Contact

Bloggers' Books

Links

Search

Subscribe

Enter your email address to subscribe to the AIDP Blog feed via e-mail:

Subscribe to the AIDP Blog's Comment Feed.

Int.l Criminal Law News

The latest international criminal law news from the Google news reader:

Meta Information

Statistics

In total, there have been 13585 unique visitors to the AIDP Blog. Within the past hour, this blog has had 0 hits.

AIDP Blog | American National Section | Terms | Site by Blog What Design

AIDP Blog | American National Section | Terms | Site by Blog What Design

Close
E-mail It